Skip navigation links
Overview
Best Evidence Medical Education
Books for Medical Educators
Career Advising Program
Curriculum Content
Education Scholar Modules
Fast Facts About Osteopathic Medical Education
MedEd Update
Medical Education Journal Review
Medical Education Mini-Grants
National Academy of Osteopathic Medical Educators
Osteopathic Medical Education Research Institute
Reports from Medical Education Conferences
Society of Osteopathic Medical Educators
Scholars-in-Residence Program

The Use of Qualitative Research Criteria for Portfolio Assessment as an Alternative to Reliability Evaluation: a Case Study 

E. Driessen, C. Van Der Vleuten, et al.

Medical Education
February 2005, Vol. 39, Issue #2, pg. 214-220.

Review by: Linda Heun, Ph.D. <lheun@aacom.org>

The authors describe the application of qualitative research criteria to the assessment of portfolio information. This approach preserve the flexibility, personal orientation and authenticity of the qualitative information contained in such tools. Essential elements of the process were:

  • feedback cycles during the development of the portfolio so that final recommendations were not a surprise
  • establishing a balance between the mentor roles of coach and assessor
  • student involvement in decisions to promote buy-in and the expression of alternative viewpoints
The authors describe the implementation of a case study using five qualitative research strategies: triangulation, prolonged engagement, member checking, audit trail and dependability audit.

For more information about this article and author(s), visit the Medical Education website.

Articles from Medical Education

Research Articles

 
 

American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine
5550 Friendship Boulevard, Suite 310, Chevy Chase, MD 20815-7231   P 301.968.4100  F 301.968.4101

© 2008-2010 AACOM. All rights reserved.